Sadly, this book just didn’t work for me. I feel like it’s been overhyped, and I must have had a different experience than most readers because I don’t understand the rave reviews. The writing came across as immature and unpolished to me. There was an obscene amount of cursing, which felt over the top and ridiculous. Additionally, it’s an open-door romance, which isn’t my preference, so I ended up skipping those parts in the audiobook since I prefer closed-door romances.
The book felt overly focused on ticking diversity boxes and pandering, with a wide array of ethnicities and sexual orientations represented. While diversity is important, it came across as forced rather than natural, which detracted from the story. Also, the messaging about feeling ‘othered’ and not fitting into society felt heavy-handed and preachy. I prefer my entertainment to convey its themes more subtly, without feeling like I’m being lectured to.
Overall, the plot was boring, the characters felt one-dimensional and fell flat, there was zero chemistry between the couple, and the writing came off as too juvenile. While I appreciated the magical elements, they weren’t developed enough to compensate for the rest. Unfortunately, this author’s style just isn’t for me, and I wouldn’t recommend this book. There are way better witchy books and cozy fantasy books.
**This book is part of a witchy real-time reaction episode, which you can listen to here.
