This started off slow for me, so I will say it is a bit of a slow burn. There is a lot of tension and conflict built up between the characters, which adds a nice suspense and mystery to the story. For most of the book, we know someone was killed, but we’re trying to figure out who died, who killed them, and then why. As the story unfolded and we learned more information about people and the things that happened in the past, I began to figure out what was going on. I had some good guesses that turned out to be true. So while I wouldn’t say this is predictable, it does fit a formula that I figured out as I was listening to the book. So the big reveal at the end didn’t take me by that much surprise because I had deduced it ahead of time. But it was still a good mystery to solve. With all the different characters, it felt a bit like the board or movie Clue. We have all these suspects with motives to kill, lots of lies and secrets between everyone, and a mystery to solve, so that was fun.

As for the characters, there were a few that were likable, but many were not. There was also a lot of gossip, petty drama, and childish, immature behavior, especially from the groomsmen. I found it all a bit annoying. However, all of the main characters had distinct personalities and voices, so if I had not been listening to the audiobook and actually reading the book, I still would have known who was who. It wasn’t confusing to keep everyone straight. And by the end, it all makes sense and fits together perfectly, like a puzzle. We get glimpses of each character, but it doesn’t go too in-depth with each person, but overall, it’s a pretty rich description of everyone.

I also enjoyed the setting of this story. We’re on a remote Irish island that gave me gothic vibes. It’s eerie. It’s creepy and a bit spooky. The weather is bad, so that adds some stress and tension. There are rocky cliffs, caves, and difficult terrain, the electricity goes out, and the internet connection goes in and out. So the circumstances that everyone finds themselves in with these frustrating conditions add to the unsettling feelings that build throughout the book. It’s very atmospheric.

One thing that bothered me was the amount of foul language used in this book. It felt like lazy writing from the author and was unnecessary. There is also one steamy scene, but it isn’t graphic. I don’t need this in my thrillers. Also, trigger warnings for cutting, thoughts of suicide, and abortion. I will try another book or two by this author.