3.5 stars
I’m a big fan of this author and have enjoyed several of her other books, so I was excited to dive into her debut. Unfortunately, it didn’t quite meet my expectations. While her prose is beautiful, the story itself felt slow, with a lot of words but not much action. It leaned more toward historical mystery than a magical, witchy tale, and I found myself wanting more enchantment and fantastical elements.
The teenage romance was sweet but felt like insta-love—a trope that’s not my favorite. On the positive side, the spooky, gothic atmosphere gave it a dark, fairytale vibe, which I appreciated. Still, I was hoping for a bit more depth and magic overall.
If you’re new to this author, I’d recommend starting with her later works, which showcase her talent more fully. But if you’re a fan and curious to see where she began, this debut might still be worth a read—just don’t expect it to be the most magical of witchy books.
**This book is part of a witchy real-time reaction episode, which you can listen to here.
